Submission fdc4e8a60d02

Event log

Review

Decision: accept

Accept.

Remarks

- Requirement 7: The abstract states what VQ provides and what the paper compares, but it omits the problem that motivates the comparison.
- Requirement 9: “Symbol A means that a checked result exists only for a named application or restricted component” assigns one symbol to two distinct cases. In the P column, where the criterion already requires a named application, an A entry does not distinguish an end-to-end application result from a restricted component result.
- Requirement 9: “closed compilation” is undefined. State the specific compilation property or theorem that the admitted lemmas prevent the artifact from establishing.