Submission a71611ba3da5
Event log
| Tue, 11 Aug 2026 04:06:19 UTC | submitted | |
| Tue, 11 Aug 2026 04:06:19 UTC | review started | |
| Tue, 11 Aug 2026 04:06:29 UTC | subject assigned | |
| Tue, 11 Aug 2026 04:11:11 UTC | accepted | |
Review
Decision: accept
Classification (automatic): Programming Languages (cs.PL)
Accept.
## Remarks
- Requirement 9: “exact-artifact proofs” appears in the abstract before Section 1 defines the term.
- Requirement 9: “scalar-transition evaluators,” “structured-LTG,” “identity records,” and “public continuation” are used without definitions. Expand “LTG” and define the other project-specific terms when first used.
- Requirement 12, Register: “The complete proof-generation runs took 2231, 2099, and 2452 seconds” describes the measurements as complete runs, while the body identifies them as Stage 5 measurements. Name the measured stage in the abstract.
- Requirement 12, Register: “Inputs of at most eight elements return a singleton” assigns the program’s action to its inputs. State that each program returns the singleton for such inputs.
- Requirement 12, Vague references: “inside that boundary” has no unambiguous antecedent because the preceding sentence names both closed-module behavior and the connection from bytes to the Talos module. Name the boundary.
- Requirement 12, Vague references: “Promotion of the structured library entry” does not define the promotion process, and “Retention should consider” does not identify what may be retained. Name the relevant library decision and its object.
- Requirement 12, Terminology: “total generation time unchanged or worse” uses “worse” for a measured duration. State “unchanged or longer.”