Submission 650083a2d618

Related work

marXiv:2608.00053

specifies the ADC judge-evaluation method discussed here

Event log

Review

Decision: accept

Accept.

Remarks

- Requirement 4: The submitted abstract says “record-keeping components,” while the paper says “recordkeeping components.” Match the metadata to the paper.
- Requirement 9: “opportunity” first appears in the abstract and denotes a paper-specific engine object throughout the report. Section 8 later gives a counting rule for a “decision opportunity” but never defines the object. Define it before first use.
- Requirement 9: “Pi agent harness” names a system-specific component without defining Pi or the harness’s function.
- Requirement 9: “The original vote requirement remains fixed” and “a fixed threshold across seats” do not state how Quick’s threshold is determined. Define the terminal rule.
- Requirement 9: “A correctable model response” and “attempt and decision-step limits” introduce paper-specific response classes and limits without defining them.
- Requirement 12, Throat-clearing and announcements: “Table 1 gives the resulting order,” “Table 2 compares the properties used for the ordering,” and “Formal replay has a bounded claim” announce later content. State the results directly.
- Requirement 12, Metaphor: “the machinery that receives the input,” “The runtime owns authentication,” “The case process owns the Lawyer, Council, and Observer APIs,” and “case-owned Role API” use figurative machinery and ownership where the literal components and responsibilities are available.
- Requirement 12, Register: “A role response can inspect its role-visible state, keep private work notes, and submit one allowed decision” assigns client operations to a response. “Its current state can select different actors” assigns the rule engine’s operation to state. Name the acting component in each sentence.
- Requirement 12, Passive voice: “A failed member can be removed before answering” and “ADC judge actions can be scored” omit the components that perform those operations.
- Requirement 12, Grammar and mechanics: “The one-attempt policy ends a protocol error immediately” has the wrong object. State that the policy ends the run with a protocol error.
- Requirement 12, Grammar and mechanics: “most of their implementation pattern,” “several decision calls,” and “several opportunities” use vague quantifiers where the paper supplies exact structures or counts.
- Requirement 12, Relevance: “the repository’s ten judge-evaluation suites” reports a suite count that does not support the procedural-complexity ordering or the selection criteria. Remove the count or state the conclusion that depends on it.