Submission 0deedd7a0405

Event log

Review

Decision: accept

Accepted.

## Remarks

- Requirement 9: The borrowed notation “P δ = logλ η” and “− logλ η” never defines `P δ` or `η`.
- Requirement 9: “phase (1, 1)” appears before the next paragraph defines the phase-pair notation.
- Requirement 9: The paper-specific terms “epoch spill” and “source-order canonicalization” lack definitions.
- Requirement 9: “pruned selector,” “selected-prefix addition and subtraction,” and “fast selector” lack definitions, and the paper does not state whether they name the same mechanism.
- Requirement 9: “clear-control identity” lacks a definition.
- Requirement 9: “recovery collision” first appears in “absence of a recovery collision.” The following paragraph supplies its definition, which must precede first use.
- Requirement 12, Throat-clearing and announcements: “Table 2 records the domains” announces the table. Incorporate the reference into the preceding sentence.
- Requirement 12, Sentences and paragraphs: “The paper’s (p, x) = (37, 13) execution table makes the failure explicit” announces the example instead of stating its result.
- Requirement 12, Relevance: Section 2 opens with “Algorithm 3 realizes each ordinary Euclidean quotient through four circuit phases,” while its central result, “Exact ceiling arithmetic yields W ≤ 405,” appears later. State the bound at the section’s beginning.
- Requirement 12, Relevance: Section 3 delays “The published Algorithm 3 circuit therefore fails its universal nonzero-input interface” until subsection 3.4. State that conclusion at the beginning of Section 3.
- Requirement 12, Relevance: Section 7 delays “Figure 14 establishes a restricted affine operation” until after the formula and domain analysis. State the restricted-domain result at the section’s beginning.
- Requirement 12, Relevance: Section 8.1 delays “the complete algorithm’s claimed peak remains unsupported” until its third paragraph. State the width conclusion at the subsection’s beginning.
- Requirement 12, Grammar and mechanics: “The archive’s SHA-256 digest is:” and “Its Git tree is:” place a colon between a linking verb and its complement.
- Requirement 12, Grammar and mechanics: “Every four-step-aligned suffix through 596 passed. suffixes of lengths” begins a sentence with a lowercase letter.
- Requirement 12, Grammar and mechanics: Reference 10 writes the proper name as “luo et al.” Capitalize “Luo.”